ShadowTyping

QWERTY vs Dvorak vs Colemak: Should You Switch?

8 min read · 1 October 2026

Almost every keyboard you will meet uses the QWERTY layout, but alternatives exist, and people argue about them with surprising passion. Here is a plain look at the three best-known layouts, what each one actually offers, and whether switching is worth the effort.

QWERTY

QWERTY gets its name from the first six letters on the top row. It comes from the typewriters of the 1870s and became the default everywhere as typewriters, and later computers, spread. It is not designed for comfort: many common letters sit off the home row, and some of the most common letter pairs are typed by the same finger. But it is what shortcuts, games and other people's computers expect.

Dvorak

Dvorak was designed in the 1930s with the aim of reducing finger travel. It puts all the vowels under the left hand's home row and the most common consonants under the right, so that typing English alternates hands more often and fingers move less. Many users who learn it report that typing feels smoother and less tiring.

Colemak

Colemak came much later, in the 2000s. It changes only a minority of the keys from QWERTY, so it keeps familiar shortcuts such as cut, copy, paste and undo in easy reach, while moving common letters onto the home row. This makes it a gentler switch than Dvorak for people who rely on keyboard shortcuts.

Side by side

QWERTYDvorakColemak
Designed1870s, for typewriters1930s, for comfort and efficiency2000s, as a modern, gentler alternative
Home row lettersA S D F G H J K LA O E U I D H T N SA R S T D H N E I O
Keys changed from QWERTYNoneAlmost all lettersA minority of letters
Shortcuts (copy, paste)Standard positionsMoved, awkward on one handMostly kept
AvailabilityEverywhereBuilt into most major operating systemsBuilt into some systems, a free download for others
Time to relearnNoneOften weeks to monthsOften a few weeks

Is switching worth it?

  • Speed: there is no clear proof that an alternative layout makes most people faster. Practice and technique matter far more.
  • Comfort: some people report less finger movement and strain. That is a real reason, but a personal one, and people with no comfort problem may not notice a difference.
  • Cost: expect weeks of being slower while you relearn, and awkwardness whenever you use a QWERTY keyboard, such as a friend's laptop or a work PC.
  • Compatibility: shared computers, games and keyboard shortcuts are all designed around QWERTY. Some games assume the key positions of QWERTY for movement.
  • Physical keyboards: the printed letters will not match what you type unless you buy blank keycaps or a keyboard for that layout, which is fine if you touch type.

If you do want to try

  1. Choose one layout and commit for at least a month. Switching back and forth keeps you slow.
  2. Learn it the way you would learn to touch type again: home row first, then the other rows. See the home row guide.
  3. Practise for 15 to 20 minutes a day and keep your eyes on the screen.
  4. Track your progress with typing tests. This site supports QWERTY, Dvorak and Colemak: choose yours in the layout menu above the test, so the mistake map shows the right keys.
  5. Keep the ability to use QWERTY, since you will meet it everywhere.

Our advice

If you are not curious about alternative layouts, stay with QWERTY and spend the time on technique instead, because proper touch typing makes a far bigger difference than the layout. If you are curious, or you have discomfort that you think comes from finger movement, Colemak is the easiest switch and Dvorak is the classic choice. Either way, try it as an experiment, give it a month, and let your own results decide.

Whatever layout you choose, the basics stay the same: accuracy first, relaxed hands, daily practice. Start with a 1 minute typing test and see where you are today.

How fast do you type right now?

Take a free test, no sign-up needed.

Start typing test

Keep reading